The Fate of Nicholas Scratch in Agatha All Along

The finale of Agatha All Along finally revealed the long-mysterious fate of Agatha Harkness’s son, Nicholas Scratch, a character whose whereabouts had been a subject of speculation since WandaVision.

The Mystery of Nicholas Scratch

Since WandaVision, fans have been wondering about the fate of Nicholas Scratch, with many theories emerging. Some speculated that he might appear alongside his mother in the series, or that he could be sacrificed for the Darkhold or become a servant of Mephisto. However, the truth revealed in Agatha All Along is far more tragic and poignant.

In the final episode of Agatha All Along, the story flashes back to the 1700s, showing Agatha’s difficult birth in the woods. Death, personified as Rio, arrives to claim her child, implying that Nicholas would be stillborn. Agatha pleads for her child’s life, and Death agrees to give them “more time” rather than taking the child immediately.

Nicholas is described as being “made from Scratch,” a term that contrasts with the comic book allusion to the Devil, “Old Scratch.” This origin story underscores the natural and emotional bond between Agatha and her son, rather than any supernatural or malevolent influence.

Agatha and Nicholas spend their lives wandering and killing covens of witches. This is not just for survival or power but also to placate Death, ensuring that Nicholas could continue living his borrowed life. Agatha’s actions are driven by her desperate attempt to protect her son from the inevitable return of Death.

The finale reveals that the one time Nicholas failed to help his mother kill witches, Death came for him. Under the cover of darkness, Death whisked Nicholas away, leading him to the afterlife while Agatha was left behind, heartbroken and fearful of her son’s judgment.

Legacy and Future Implications

Agatha’s grief and guilt over Nicholas’s death shape her character and actions throughout the series. She continues to manipulate and use others to maintain her power and keep her son’s memory alive. In a final act, Agatha attempts to bring Nicholas back by planting a seed with a piece of his hair and her own tear, leaving a glimmer of hope for his potential return in future Marvel stories.

In summary, the fate of Nicholas Scratch is a tale of tragic love and sacrifice, highlighting Agatha’s relentless efforts to protect her son and the devastating consequences that follow when those efforts fail.